Winter Safety Pool Covers: Costs vs Benefits

safety-cover-invented by meyco productsNot sure if you’ve noticed, but the sun is setting earlier. Pretty soon, the leaves will start to change and it will be time to close the pool for winter.

Safety Covers for in ground pools and for some above ground pools that have decks – are they worth the extra cost?

In today‚Äôs blog, we’ll compare some Costs vs. Benefits of safety covers.

Why Use Safety Covers?

The number one reason pool owners invest in safety covers is to provide safety and prevent accidental intrusion by children, pets, or other animals. According to the CDC, nearly 60% of all drowning deaths for children under 15, occurred at a private in-ground pool.

A common problem that we hear talking to our customers is that they have algae growth when they open the pool for the first time during the spring. Solid safety covers help eliminate algae growth over winter. Algae can potentially stain the pool and will cause more headaches come spring time.

Winter Covers vs. Safety Covers

Winter Covers

solid-pool-coversA winter cover is essentially a large, oversized tarp to prevent debris from getting into the pool, and minimizes algae growth over winter. Winter covers can last on average 3-5 years and will then need to be replaced with new.

Having to replacing a winter cover every 3 years or so can become very costly. Winter covers are good for a budget conscious pool owner and usually do a good job of keeping debris from getting into the pool, but in the long run, they can cost more.

Winter Cover Advantages

  • Cost is low, most pools can be covered for $200-$400.
  • Keeps the pool very clean, blocks all sun.
  • Initial Installation is easier than a safety cover.
  • Quick availability.

Winter Cover Disadvantages

  • Durability. Tree branches, heavy snow and rain can damage.
  • Water bags. Ugly, slimy and 2 or 3 seem to break every year.
  • Non-Safe. Floating pool covers are unsafe for kids and animals.

Safety CoversBubbles the elephant can stand on a Loop-Loc safety cover

Safety pool covers are made of a stronger material than winter covers. Covers are able to withstand a break strength of 4000 pounds. Yes, that means that a baby elephant can stand on a safety cover!

This makes safety covers much more durable than floating winter pool covers, and much longer lasting.

Safety Cover Advantages

  • Safety. Will prevent access to pool, and supports thousands of pounds.
  • Looks great. Neat and clean, almost elegant.
  • Low maintenance. Easy to put on and remove.
  • Better fit for pools with raised walls, spas or water falls.

Safety Cover Disadvantages

  • Cost. Safety covers can cost 2-4 times as much as a winter cover.
  • Installation requires a hammer drill, and half a day of labor.
  • Custom shaped safety covers can take 3-4 weeks to fabricate.

Initially, safety covers may seem high in price but over the course of the years, it will pay for itself over time. It is important to get a safety cover that is properly sized as it is going to ensure the longest life of the cover. If the cover is not sized properly, it voids the warranty and you will not get the longest life of the cover.

On average, safety covers last 12 years. The covers can last longer than that by taking proper care of the covers, and stored in a cool dry area when they are not in use.

Mesh vs. Solid Safety Covers

Once you decide if you want to invest in a safety cover, the next step is to determine the type of cover. There are tightly woven mesh safety covers, shown below left, and a reinforced vinyl material used for solid safety covers. Both types are anchored into a surrounding pool deck.

safety-covers mesh-and-solidMesh Advantages

  • Mesh material is a lot lighter and easier to handle.
  • Rain water and melting snow passes through the mesh material into the pool.
  • Leaves and debris are collected on top and makes for an easier spring clean up.
  • The cost of a mesh safety cover is less expensive than a solid safety cover.

Mesh Disadvantages

  • Allows sunlight to penetrate through which contributes to algae growth.
  • Fine particles such as silt can make its way through the cover.

Solid Advantages

  • Blocks 100% of sunlight which prevents algae growth and an easy spring clean up.
  • Prevents fine particles from entering the pool and accumulating over winter.
  • Strong material resists damage from tree branches or animals.

Solid Disadvantages

  • Solid covers tend to be heavier in weight.
  • Safety covers with drain panels allow particulates and spores to wash into pool.
  • Safety covers that use a cover pump to pump the water off need to be maintained.

The Bottom Line. Paying more up front for a safety cover is going to be more cost effective in the long run. The quality of safety covers, 3-5x longer life expectancy, great looks and low maintenance are added benefits. More importantly, safety is the number one reason to buy a safety pool cover. Safety Covers remove all pool worries when you put them on.

If you have any questions or need help with any aspect of covering your pool for winter, our experts are standing by 24/7. Call us at 800-288-7946.

Kristine Malak
InTheSwim Staff Blogger



Winter Safety Pool Covers: Costs vs Benefits — 2 Comments

  1. I’ve only had my pool a few years and use a standard pool cover. can’t wrap my head around a “safety” cover that let’s water and silt thru. I have a lot of trees (neighbors) around and the crap I get on my pool cover I wouldn’t want getting into my pool. I understand the safety aspect but just think the spring cleanup would be a mess. Am I over thinking this?

    • Hi Rick, there’s nothing better than pulling off a solid pool cover to blue and only slightly hazy pool water. But one of these years, a hole will develop, perhaps a big one, and all that sludge slips into the pool, unless you manage to avoid that eventual event. My favorite personal cover choice is a solid safety cover, without drain panels. You still need to pump off the cover, but it will never tear, and because it’s taut, it’s much easier to keep clean, as compared to water bag solid covers. Mesh safety covers can produce a messy pool in spring, if you have a lot of deciduous trees around, with lots of spring debris and pollen. It can be avoided however, with more chemicals used, either an additional spring dose of algaecide and/or chlorine, and if your pool filter is efficient, the water looks good in 24 hours, but yeah, I understand what you’re saying. It’s may even out though, all-in-all, because the safety cover is so easy to remove and store, but now the pool will need more cleaning, yeah…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *